#310 - The Fraud Triangle: Is Your Business Vulnerable?
Ever had a trusted employee rip you off? When I spoke with a bar owner recently, she was still in shock after uncovering a six-figure fraud carried out by a 'trusted' manager over more than 4 years. I hope that doesn't sound familiar.
Most people who commit fraud against their employer are not career criminals. The vast majority are trusted staff who have no criminal history and don't even consider themselves lawbreakers. Donald Cressey, a criminologist, calls it the Fraud Triangle. He says there are three factors that must be present for an ordinary person to commit fraud: Pressure, Opportunity and Rationalisation. Think about how this could apply at your business:
- Pressure comes from a 'non-shareable' financial problem that can't be shared or solved in a legitimate way. It might a drug or gambling addiction, desire to impress friends or problems with a loan that must be repaid urgently. Non-shareable problems involve some sort of embarrassment or shame. They threaten the fraudster's status as a person who is trusted by others. In almost every fraud case, their financial problem relates to gaining or maintaining status.
- Opportunity arises when the fraudster sees a way to use their position of trust to solve the financial problem, knowing they are unlikely to be caught. Think of all the opportunities that arise with money handling at your business: balancing the cash against the till readout, counting cash, making up floats, 'correcting' over-rings and errors. Lax stock-control with liquor or expensive food items gives plenty of opportunity to trade these items for cash. Most hospitality businesses offer wonderful opportunities for fraudsters, with little monitoring of warning signs and sloppy cash control systems .
- Rationalisation is the third part of the triangle. Cressey says most fraudsters are first-time offenders with no criminal record. They see themselves as ordinary, honest people who are caught in a bad situation. This lets them justify the crime to themselves in a way that makes it acceptable or justifiable. They may say they were 'just borrowing it', felt they were entitled to it, had to look after their family or felt they were being underpaid and therefore deserved it. Sometimes they feel the employer is dishonest and should be 'sharing the spoils'.
Prevention is possible in all 3 parts of the triangle. Do you have your 'sources' for information about staff problems? Ideally, regular staff reviews will give you an understanding of the 'whole person' and their needs. Drug, alcohol and financial counselling services are widely available, but you need to be bold to suggest them - it's difficult for some people. Tight checks and balances with cash and stock handling will eliminate most opportunities, with unexpected spot-checks to keep people on their toes. Plus a clear division of labour between those who count and those who check the figures - whether it's cash, wine or stock. Would an external stocktake service really be so expensive if it meant the job was done properly? Is there a good reason why the cost percentages in your Recipe Software are lower than the monthly food cost percentage? Or not. Your Code of Conduct should also talk clearly about the value of integrity and honest dealings in the business, so rationalisation is harder: 'but nobody said I couldn't borrow!'. This is not about staff needing a sainthood as a condition of employment, but there are too many times that trust is misplaced through naivete or laziness. Wake up! Ready Reference & Downloads for 1st Class Members:
99 Ways Staff Steal from a Restaurant, Hotel or Bar - a very useful checklist of the many ways thieves work.
Honesty Questions for Staff & Management Interviews - make it clear right from the beginning that integrity is an important part of the job role.
Warning Signs of Employee Fraud and Stealing - how to pick up the early signals that indicate problems.
32 Cash Register & Point of Sale Control Systems - take a step-by-step approach to ensuring internal thieves can't help themselves.
If Staff Did This, Would You Call It Stealing? - how many 'grey areas' are there in your business? When rules are unclear, some staff will make up their own...
Staffing and Staff Management Dept with dozens of resource articles on key issues. >> Download the hundreds of Staff Manuals and Forms - ready when you need them.
>> Download Cost Control & Profit Calculators to pinpoint problem areas fast!
>>> Click to Join Profitable Hospitality and Start Running a More Successful Business.
2010 Training & Events Calendar
Starting a Cafe or Restaurant Workshop - 7 or 21 August in Sydney
>>> Effective Online Marketing: 1 Day Workshop for Clubs - Sydney 29 July, Brisbane 3 August
Internet Marketing Workshops - see the wide range offered in Sydney every month.
DVD Set: Club Food & Beverage Management Summit - ORDER NOW: huge value in this 4-DVD set, with 13 presentations from the Oct 2009 event. Great for building staff and manager skills - check the preview video online. With warm regards -
Share your Comments and Suggestions: Add your name beside Login, and your ideas where it says 'What's on your mind...'
|
Restaurant Management
